Best Payroll Services for Nonprofits | Compare Quotes

  • Compare Up to 5 Free Quotes from nonprofit payroll services companies
  • It takes less than 60 seconds or less to fill.
  • There is no obligation to accept any offer.
  • 100% Free.

As a nonprofit owner, you’re responsible for your employees’ payroll taxes, as well as countless reports, filing deadlines, and manual steps required by the IRS. The time, effort, and money needed for compliance are staggering, to say the least.

There are many nonprofit payroll services that will make it easier for you to comply with the law, improving your efficiency and productivity by automating the whole payroll process.

To do: All you have to do is fill out a form (it takes less than a minute) and get up to five reputable payroll services for not for profits provider quotes to compare payroll service options and secure the best payroll for nonprofits.

best Payroll Services for Nonprofits

For Small Business:

Choosing the Right Payroll Service for Nonprofits

A payroll service is a crucial resource for any business or organization, but selecting the appropriate payroll for non profit organizations can be even more important if you’re a nonprofit. Nonprofits frequently have specific requirements and needs, which can make picking the correct payroll service more difficult.

Here are 10 top things that I highly recommend taking into consideration when selecting a payroll solution for nonprofits to ensure you get the best service possible.

CriteriaDetailsImportancePriority Level
1. CompliancePayroll service must understand nonprofit tax laws and regulations.Ensures tax-exempt status and avoids penalties.High
2. CostService should fit your nonprofit’s budget, possibly through flat-rate or subscription pricing.Enables directing more funds towards the mission.High
3. FeaturesLook for nonprofit-specific features, such as volunteer time tracking, donation management, or grant tracking.Simplifies and enhances nonprofit management.Medium
4. Ease of UseThe service should be user-friendly and require minimal training.Saves time and reduces errors.Medium
5. Customer SupportReliable and readily available customer support is vital.Ensures smooth operations and quick resolution of issues.High
6. IntegrationService should integrate with other software like accounting or volunteer management systems.Enhances efficiency by allowing seamless data flow.Medium
7. SecurityChoose a service prioritizing financial data security, using encryption and two-factor authentication.Prevents financial loss and reputation damage.High
8. ScalabilityService should grow with your organization.Allows growth without needing to switch services.Low
9. ReputationPositive testimonials from other nonprofits are crucial.Indicates reliability and high-quality service.Medium
10. CustomizationService should offer customization for your nonprofit’s needs.Ensures efficiency by catering to specific needs.Medium

Best Payroll Services for Nonprofits

Nonprofits have unique payroll needs and often require customized solutions to manage them. Finding the best payroll service for small nonprofits or large organizations can be a challenge, as there are many local and national companies that provide payroll services.

To make the process easier, I highly recommend comparing multiple non profit payroll service providers to get the best deals.

#1.Compare Payroll Services for Nonprofits

In order to receive quotes for payroll services for non profits, all you have to do is fill out a form (it takes less than a minute), and you will receive up to five quotes from reputable payroll service providers for nonprofits to compare payroll service options and secure the best payroll for charities.

Compare Payroll Services for Nonprofits

#2. ADP Workforce

ADP is a comprehensive solution provider for nonprofits and social service organizations, offering tailored payroll and HR solutions. Their services range from employee hours tracking, record keeping, talent management, onboarding training, and automated allocation of employee compensation.

ADP Workforce
CriteriaDetailsImportance for Decision Making
Service TypePayroll and HR solutionsHigh
Target MarketNonprofits and social services organizations and moreHigh
Unique Selling PropositionDesigned specifically for nonprofits and social services, with input from clientsMedium
Offered FeaturesEmployee hours tracking, record keeping, talent management, onboarding training, automated allocation of employee compensationHigh
Special OfferThree months free when signing up for payroll processingMedium
Analytics and BenchmarksData analysis tools and benchmarking data from over 40 million employeesMedium
Customer SupportSales and support contact numbers available on siteLow
HR Outsourcing OptionsOffers options for outsourcing payroll and HR tasksHigh
TestimonialsTestimonials from other nonprofits available on siteLow

#3. Patriot Software

Patriot Software offers nonprofit employers comprehensive payroll services at an affordable cost. It allows users to process paychecks in one step, as well as automate tasks like deductions and employee reimbursements.

Plus, it supports common accounting software integrations like QuickBooks and Sage 50 Accounting.

#4. Gusto

Gusto is another popular choice for nonprofits with its user-friendly interface and customizable features.

The service provides automated payments with electronic direct deposits, health insurance management tools for tracking employee benefits and tax filing services for end of year returns.

Plus Gusto offers live customer support 24/7 to answer any questions you may have about the service.

These three options provide nonprofit employers with comprehensive solutions for managing their organization’s payroll needs.

With customizable features and reliable customer support teams available around the clock, these payroll solutions make it easier than ever before for nonprofits to stay on top of their finances without sacrificing convenience or quality of service.

What Questions to Ask When Looking for Nonprofit Payroll Services

To get quality nonprofit payroll services, you need to ask these questions in order to get services that are affordable and provide excellent services.

Do they offer specialized services?

Many payroll services are designed with businesses in mind, which can make them difficult to adapt to nonprofits.

Make sure your chosen provider offers specialized services specifically tailored to nonprofits, such as options that handle donations and grants.

How much do they charge?

Cost is always an important factor when selecting any kind of service, especially for nonprofits whose budgets are often tight. Get quotes from multiple providers and compare them side-by-side before making your decision.

You should also look into whether there are any hidden fees, such as setup costs or annual charges, that may not be apparent at first glance.

What kind of customer support do they offer?

If something goes wrong with your payroll system, you want to be sure you have reliable customer support on hand who can help get everything back up and running quickly.

Look into what kind of customer support your potential provider offers, such as phone lines or online chat, and find out what their response times typically look like before signing up with them.

Are their security measures up-to-date?

When it comes to handling sensitive data such as employee records and financial information, security should always be your top priority, so make sure your chosen provider takes appropriate measures to keep that data safe from outside threats such as hackers or malware attacks.

Ask questions about their security protocols and find out what kinds of encryption methods they use to protect data both in transit and at rest on their servers.

I know that it requires some time to do these, but I think it is worth the time and money in the long run.

What is a Nonprofit organization?

According to Cornell LII, a non-profit organization is one that neither makes a profit nor pays any of its staff or board members a salary.

While the primary objective of most corporations is to make a profit, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) have as their main objective to link those in need with those who can help. The ability of this sector to offer fundamental services like healthcare, education, and psychological treatment depends heavily on private charity from individuals, corporations, and foundations.

Through providing access to new educational possibilities, scientific advancements, public advocacy initiatives, disaster relief, and other forms of aid, nonprofit organizations support the growth of individuals and communities.

How Payroll Services Help Nonprofits Succeed 

Let’s take a look at three key benefits of using payroll services for nonprofits. 

Accuracy and Efficiency 

Accuracy is the main benefit of employing a payroll service.

Payroll services offer precise computations that are error-free. This ensures adherence to all relevant laws and regulations while assisting in the reduction of calculation errors.

Additionally, payroll services save time by automating procedures like tax preparation, wage garnishments, and other challenging jobs that would otherwise consume a lot of your staff’s time.

Using an automated system allows you to avoid becoming bogged down in paperwork and instead focus on other critical aspects of your organization.

Cost Savings   

Another benefit of using payroll services for nonprofits is cost savings. Outsourcing your payroll to a professional company eliminates the need for hiring additional staff or purchasing costly software programs to manage payroll in-house.

Additionally, since these companies specialize in this field they are often able to complete tasks faster than if you did it yourself – resulting in lower labor costs overall.

Finally, they will guarantee that you are in compliance with all applicable rules and regulations so that you do not face any potential penalties as a result of non-compliance concerns. 


Finally, another benefit of using a payroll service is security. Most reputable companies offer secure encryption technology that ensures the safety of your data at all times.

This implies that your personal information will be safe from unwanted access or malicious actions like identity theft or data breaches, which could cost your company thousands or even millions of dollars in damages if not properly safeguarded.

Leave a Reply